Guide · Commissions

Medicare chargebacks explained: what they cost and which ones are wrong

How Medicare Advantage and Part D chargebacks work, what they cost, and the cases where a carrier can't take the whole payment back.

When carriers take money back

CMS requires Medicare Advantage and Part D carriers to recover agent compensation in two cases: when a client makes any plan change in the first three months of enrollment, called rapid disenrollment, and for any month a client wasn't enrolled but you were paid for it.

How much they take

  • Rapid disenrollment: the whole payment.
  • Any other time a client leaves: only the months they weren't enrolled.

An example with round numbers: say you were paid $600 up front for a first-year enrollment. If the client changes plans in month two, all $600 comes back. If they leave after month eight, the carrier recovers the four months they weren't enrolled, $200.

Full chargebacks CMS doesn't allow

The whole-payment rule for rapid disenrollment doesn't apply in a list of cases, including when the client:

  • enrolled effective October 1, November 1 or December 1 and changed plans during AEP for January 1
  • died
  • moved out of the plan's service area
  • was in a plan that terminated or wasn't renewed
  • became dually eligible or qualified for Extra Help
  • gained or lost employer or union coverage
  • moved into a five-star plan

In those cases the carrier can still recover months the client wasn't enrolled, but not the whole payment.

Catching the wrong ones

  1. Check every chargeback on every statement against the client's record.
  2. Note the effective date and the date of the change. That tells you whether it was rapid disenrollment at all.
  3. If the amount or the reason is wrong, dispute it in writing and cite 42 CFR 422.2274(d)(5) for Medicare Advantage or 423.2274(d)(5) for Part D.
  4. Do it promptly. Carriers settle retroactive changes back through the previous calendar year, and older mistakes get much harder to recover.

How Anviik helps

Anviik reads each statement you upload and marks every chargeback line, so you can check each one against the client's record in a minute. It also flags active clients missing from a statement. The full statement checklist.

Checked November 12, 2026 against 42 CFR 422.2274(d) and 423.2274(d). The example amounts are made up; your carrier contracts set your actual rates.

What are missed payments costing you?

Put your own numbers into the free commission leak calculator and see a yearly estimate.